Comments

Comments let you have a conversation in the place the conversation is about: on the transaction you can't code, or on the GST return you're about to file. Anyone with access to the entity can read and reply, clients included, so the question and the answer end up attached to the record rather than buried in an email thread. If you have come from Xero, this covers the ground that Discuss and Ask cover between them.

The difference worth knowing about: a conversation has a state. Every thread is open until someone on your team resolves it, open counts show on the row and the tab, and a new reply reopens a resolved thread automatically, so a client answering an old query puts it back in front of you instead of quietly landing in a thread nobody re-reads.


Where you can comment

Anywhere a bank transaction appears, and on a GST return as a whole.

On a transaction

In the transactions list, on both the Unreconciled and Reconciled tabs, each row carries a pill next to the description. When a transaction has comments the pill shows a speech bubble and a count; when it has nothing yet, hovering the row reveals a pencil instead.

Click the pill to open the transaction panel. Comments sit under Comments, newest last, with the box to add one at the bottom. ⌘ + Enter posts without reaching for the mouse.

The same pill appears on the journal view for a reconciled transaction, and on the transaction listings inside a GST return. There is one thread per bank transaction, no matter which of those screens you open it from. On a split, the thread sits on the transaction as a whole rather than on each line.

On several transactions at once

Select some rows, press ⌘ + K for Actions, and choose Comment on n selected. The same comment is posted to each transaction as its own thread, which is the quick way to ask one question about a batch of similar payments.

On a GST return

Open a return and go to the Activity tab. The box at the bottom posts a comment against the return itself, which is the right place for anything about the return as a whole rather than one line in it.


The Activity tab on a GST return

Activity is the consolidated view: comments on the return, comments on every transaction dated inside the return period, and the return's own history, all on one timeline in the order they happened. It is the screen to open when you pick a return back up, and it is the screen your client sees.

Transaction threads appear under a header naming the transaction, date and amount, with a Reply… box so you can answer without leaving the page.

Membership of the timeline is worked out from the transaction's date, not captured when the comment is written. So recoding a transaction, reconciling it differently, or finalising the return doesn't strand its comments. They stay with the period the money moved in. The count beside the Activity tab is the number of open conversations, so it goes down as you clear them rather than only ever going up.


Open and resolved

Resolving acts on a whole conversation, not on one comment: Resolve conversation marks every comment in that thread as dealt with and records who did it. The thread is still there, and still readable.

Two behaviours worth knowing:

  • A new comment reopens the conversation. Resolving is not a lock. If your client replies to a resolved query, or you think of something else, the thread goes back to open.
  • Only your practice can resolve. Clients can read and reply, but resolving and reopening stay on your side, so the state of a query is always your call.

Unresolve conversation puts a thread back to open deliberately.


Who can see comments

Everyone with access to the entity, including the client. That is why the composer says Visible to everyone. There are no private or internal-only comments yet, so a note you would not want the client to read doesn't belong here.

Clients see comments in their own portal under Activity, grouped by what each thread is about, and can reply from there.

Posting a comment does not email anyone by itself. If you need the client to actually respond, @-mention them. That is what sends the email. See Mentioning someone in a comment.

Replies that arrive by email

When you @-mention someone, the email they get can be answered from their inbox. They press reply, and what they write is posted here as a comment under their name. Any file they attached is filed against the transaction or return as well, so a client can send a receipt back without signing in to anything.

A comment that came in that way is marked Sent via email, so you can tell it apart from one typed into the app.

What is left out of a reply, and the reasons one might never appear, are covered in Mentioning someone in a comment.


Editing and deleting

The … menu on your own comment gives you Edit and Delete. You can edit only your own comments; practice staff can delete anyone's, which is the escape hatch for something posted on the wrong transaction or worded badly in front of a client. Deleted comments disappear from the timeline, the counts and the exports.


Attaching files

A question about a receipt usually needs the receipt. Drag a file onto the comment box, paste a screenshot straight into it, or click Paste, drop, or click to add files to pick one. Files start uploading as soon as you add them, so anything wrong with a file shows up while you are still typing rather than after you post.

The same limits apply as anywhere else in Prosaic: 20MB a file, PDFs, images, spreadsheets, Word documents, CSVs and Outlook .msg   files, and up to 10 files on one comment. A file that isn't allowed fails on its own row and leaves the rest of the comment alone.

Remove a file with the ✕ on its chip. If you remove it before posting, the file is deleted — an attachment you thought better of doesn't linger in Files. The same is true if you close the tab without posting: unposted uploads are cleared automatically within a day.

Where the file ends up

Attached files are real workspace documents, not just message contents. Each one:

  • appears in Files for the workspace, filed against the same client as the comment;
  • is attached to the record you were discussing as well as to the comment — so a receipt sent in a conversation about a transaction shows up on that transaction, and someone opening it later finds the evidence without reading the thread first;
  • carries a Comment chip in the Attached to column of Files, next to a chip for the record itself, so you can see where the file came from without opening it. The Attached to filter doesn't offer Comment yet, so you can't narrow the list down to them.

Clients can attach files too, from Activity in their portal, or by replying to a mention email with the file attached. That is the point: it is how a receipt you asked for gets back to you without a separate email to chase.

Changing attachments after posting

Edit your own comment from the … menu and you can add or remove files as well as change the wording. Removing one there detaches it from the comment but leaves the file in Files, and leaves it attached to the transaction or return — the file is still evidence about that record even if the sentence that introduced it has gone.


Comments in GST return exports

Comments can go out with the return. Under Actions → Export, Comments is one of the sections to include, and it applies to the PDF, the CSV and Excel downloads, and the emailed copy under Actions → Share.

Untick it if you are sending the return to someone who should see the figures but not the working.


Not here yet

Comments have just landed. So you know where the edges are:

  • Plain text only, up to 2,000 characters. No bold or links, and attached files sit under the comment rather than inside the text.
  • No private comments. Everything is visible to the client. A visibility control is the most likely next addition.
  • No threaded replies. Each transaction or return is one flat conversation.
  • Transactions, GST returns and journals only. Other reports and report packs can't be commented on yet.
  • No notifications except mention emails. There is no notification centre in the app, and nothing emails a client when you comment unless you mention them.

Need help?

If you are working out how to use comments with a particular client, or you want somewhere to put a note the client shouldn't see and aren't sure where that leaves you, click the 💬 button in the app or email help@prosaic.works. Comments are new and we would like to hear which part of the chase loop still feels manual.

Did this answer your question? Thanks for the feedback There was a problem submitting your feedback. Please try again later.

Still need help? Contact Us Contact Us